Bangalore |  Mysore |  Mumbai |  Pune |  Hyderabad |  Kolkata |  Delhi  
Indian Classics |  Profiles  |  Fixtures |  Video |  Archives |  Public Pulse |  In & Around |  Specials |  International |  Home  
Loading....
in   
 
News    Send comment   Send E-mail   Print the page

Karthik, Jodha face the ire of RWITC Stewards

By: True Blue   January 5 , 2010
   

In an interesting development on Sunday, the RWITC Stewards came down heavily on racing Baron M. A. M. Ramaswamy`s trainer Karthik Ganapathy and jockey T. S. Jodha by suspending them both for six months starting January 18.

The two professionals were given the above sentence after Jodha was held guilty of not allowing Golden Knight to run on its merit on Christmas Eve while Karthik was banned as the Stewards felt that the jockey would not have ridden such without the tacit approval of the trainer.

The punishment, of course, is likely to be held in abeyance till the RWITC Board of Appeal confirms the Stewards` decision against which an appeal will have already been filed by the two beleaguered professionals.
The racing fraternity here has given a guarded response to the news of the severe punishment. As a matter of fact, what has left them unimpressed is that a couple of incidents with more incriminating evidence have been handled more compassionately by the Stewards this season. What`s more, a case of clear cut case of tacit approval of the trainer also went a begging. Further, every time the Stewards have advanced the reason of being lenient on professionals considering their past record and Karthik has no history of any punishment in the past. Why no lenient view was taken in the light of this defies explanation. Also, the Stewards had punished apprentice jockey Shammi Khan for not permitting Maverick to run on merits while they did not take any action on the trainer.

There could be an endless debate about the merits, or the lack of it, in the punishment meted out to Karthik and Jodha but this is one of the rare occasions when professionals closely associated with Ramaswamy have been harshly punished by the RWITC Stewards.

In another related decision, the Stewards have suspended jockey Paul Mulrennan from January 18 till January 28 (both days inclusive) and also imposed a penalty of Rs 50,000 for careless riding astride winner Spellbinder. The fine is reportedly because the jockey aggressively argued with the Stewards.

As the Stewards have themselves observed that Paul`s offence was very close to being termed as dangerous riding, the incident certainly had enough merit for the stipendiary stewards to call for a Stewards enquiry immediately after the conclusion of the race. Punters were also amazed when the anticipated objection from Neeraj Rawal (who rode Lakhadema), who was severely interfered with by Spellbinder, didn`t materialise. Neeraj Rawal must consider himself lucky to have been let off lightly.

 
 
  Post your comments   E-mail   Print
Total Comments : 7
Posted by Suribaba on ( January 5 , 2010 )
Yes I feel its very right decision by stewards taking stern actions as they take innocent punters for easy ride & never allow horse to run on actual merits & racing syndicates doing such tactics should be severly punished
 
Posted by ramakrishna on ( January 6 , 2010 )
very unfaiir remember drakkar wydyall bend
 
Posted by rb on ( January 6 , 2010 )
it is absolutely unfair to say the least.
this is nothing but excercising authority against THE Dr M.A.M. Ramaswamy.
so typically indian, the attitude that is.
 
Posted by ygn on ( January 6 , 2010 )
Primafacie the punishment looks hard. Now I am in the USA and have been visiting races in golden gate fields. I have seen the jockeys being disqualified even for small errors - but the important thing is - the decisions are unbiased. What we have to see in Karthik`s case is whether he was let off earlier unpunished for his errors or is he being overpunished now.
If the decision is unbiased and if the stewards will stand up in future also to that standard it is good time for Indian racing. Even in the USA the racing was earlier controled by underworlds. But now that the jockeys, trainers and stewards have taken charge of racing (in the right sense) the races are really merritorious and enjoyable. Let us hope and wish good days are coming to Indian race where only merrit prevails. Racing deserves to be treated as SPORTS and not gambling.
 
Posted by Rambus on ( January 8 , 2010 )
I certainly do not agree with the author`s comments regarding the suspension of trainer Karthik G. Any intelligent racegoer who can read a race would agree that the jockey`s ride on Golden Knight was far from competent and having seen the jockey ride other horses in the same time frame, one definitely would draw the conclusion that he has not permitted his mount to run on its merits. The jockey had no concrete reason for drifting off the rails when he had a clear run and the horse was beginning to grab the bit and gallop on. Furthermore, his handling in the last two furlongs had been feeble casuing the horse to run erractically due to no assistance from the saddle. Additionally, the jockey in question would not have ridden in the manner in which he did, had the trainer not ask him to do so. I think this is a clear case where the trainer`s instructions to give the horse "a run" were carried out but caught the eyes of the stipes and stewards who have taken the action necessary to preserve the image of the sport and ensure fair racing. Kudos to Mr. Daga and his team.
 
Posted by rajmohan on ( January 6 , 2010 )
Sir,
If karthic can be suspended for the failure of golden knight, how many trainers can be allowed to function? Any number of instances can be sighted for not allowing the horse on merit.. Golden knight has generally a poor record to go by.Out of the 5 races this horse ran in poona and Mumbai,only once it placed in poona. How can a trainer be punished for not winning this horse with a poor record? There are many instaces where horses showing poor perfomances soon after winning a race. But no action.
In mumbai, there is an eyewash event called stewards enquiry. How many results reversed after stewards enquiry?When Mulrennan is suspended, How Fenton(Red Romeo) is let off? Red Romeo`s case was a fit one for reversal of the result. Yet nothing happened. So for the public, the reason for the suspension of Karthic is something else and not the perfomance of his horse.The true reason will come out after some time.
 
Posted by ramakrishna on ( January 6 , 2010 )
sir remember doi moi won when whithdrawn the runner up earlire run
 
Top
   
'


Live Results - Bangalore, June 7 2026
 
Disclaimer: The views expressed in Reviews and Analysis depict the personal perspective of the authors only. The website does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences. Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
© 2008 Racing Pulse. All Rights Reserved. A Racingpulse Holdings Venture